Sherlock Holmes And The Secret Weapon: Nigel & Basil & Watson & Holmes

This blog post is part of the Dynamic Duos of Classic Hollywood Blogathon at Classic Movie Hub. Check out more posts on a variety of Golden Age duos there!


Besides Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, no single person has had as much influence on our collective idea of Sherlock Holmes as Basil Rathbone. Despite the fact that many before had already depicted the daring detective in stage, film, and art, by sheer volume of work alone Basil Rathbone blew them all away. Together with Nigel Bruce as his trusty Dr. Watson, Rathbone played the sleuth in 14 films (briefly for Fox, later for Universal) and a successful radio program that lasted 7 years. In fact, the idea of Rathbone and Bruce as the standard for Holmes and Watson has been so entrenched in the public mind that we have forgotten how far from standard their films were. The 12 films produced by Universal pushed Holmes and Watson from foggy Victorian London to WWII, and Holmes began fighting Nazis, foiling bomb plots and flying airplanes. Despite these anachronisms, Basil Rathbone and Nigel Bruce kept the core of the characters they created intact. They proved that daring and intelligence are timeless, and unfortunately so is buffoonery.

Sherlock Holmes And The Secret Weapon was the first of the Universal series that, without any explanation, plunks Sherlock and Watson in the middle of World War II. Sherlock is tasked with protecting a Swiss scientist whose bombing device would aid Britain, but thanks to Watson’s bumbling, the scientist is captured by Moriarty. The film claims to be based on “The Adventure of the Dancing Men,” but also shows influences from “The Sign Of Four” and a few other stories. In fact, here’s how it looked on Sherlock Bingo:

Maybe we should play "Blackout" instead of "Bingo"

Maybe we should play “Blackout” instead of “Bingo”

 The main building blocks of Holmes are there, despite the updated time period. Moriarty is played with villainous glee by Lionel Atwell, who sets the stereotype of the monologuing villain in a somewhat silly scene where he details his plan to Sherlock while preparing to stuff the sleuth in a chest. Luckily, Sherlock-in-a-chest is inadvertently rescued by Inspector LeStrade and another buffoon.

The buffon in question is Nigel Bruce. Starting with The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes and continuing here, Watson slowly slipped into idiocy. Watson in the books had been a companion for Holmes who not only stood as an audience surrogate, but also humanized the detective and brought an emotional core to the series. However, Basil needs no such help. Basil as Sherlock is dashing, clever, and every bit a swashbuckling hero. (Ironic, considering his other most famous roles were playing villains to Tyrone Power and Errol Flynn.) This leaves Watson in the place of “Buffoon Sidekick.” Watson is every bit the stuffy British stereotype; he “tut-tuts” at Holmes’s dockworker disguise, loses scientists and evidence with frightening regularity, and mostly seems concerned with whether he’ll get some tea and a nap in the near future. Comic writer Kate Beaton of “Hark! A Vagrant” summed him up best:

Separating Watson of the books from Nigel Bruce, the change actually works well. Basil Rathbone verges on manic in his portrayal of Sherlock, and Bruce’s soporific Watson balances that energy. It’s a little like watching a fox jump around a panda. This balancing act makes them an engaging pair. Take, for instance, this exchange:

Dr. John H. Watson: What woman?
Sherlock Holmes: She’s blonde, five foot, full lipped and very affectionate.
Dr. John H. Watson: Oh, really? Got her phone number?

The odd couple chemistry between Holmes and Watson brings humor to a series that can (like most Universal movies at the time) verge on the dark and macabre. As an adaptation Sherlock Holmes and the Secret Weapon works well because it preserves those elements at the core of Sherlock – the sleuth story, Sherlock’s intensity and intelligence, and his attachment to Watson – while changing cosmetic details to fit the times. Ultimately, Basil and Nigel make a great duo because they are one thing above all else: a hell of a lot of fun.



About Anne Marie Kelly

Classic Film history & restoration nerd. Writer of A Year With Kate and Women's Pictures for The Film Experience. Follow me on Twitter @WeRecycleMovies.
This entry was posted in Film and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

14 Responses to Sherlock Holmes And The Secret Weapon: Nigel & Basil & Watson & Holmes

  1. I love your Sherlock Bingo!

    In his unpublished autobiography Nigel Bruce wrote about not being particularly pleased that he was asked to keep making Watson more and more the “idiot”, but the actor did what he could and, as you pointed out, in terms of the series and the “Dynamic Duo” it works very well. Whenever I read Conan Doyle or any Holmes homage, it is Basil Rathbone’s voice I hear in my head. He truly has become Holmes.

    • Anne Marie says:

      I didn’t know Nigel Bruce felt that way. I think he unfortunately becomes the scapegoat for angry Holmes fans to denounce as inauthentic. You can’t deny his chemistry with Basil Rathbone though! Thanks for the comment!

  2. Wonderful post! Basil Rathbone is a favorite of mine — whether he’s playing Sherlock Holmes or Levasseur. Love your Bingo Chart “You see but you do not observe” classic!

    • Anne Marie says:

      I’d be hard-pressed to think of a Basil Rathbone movie I didn’t like. He’s definitely an unsung great of Classic Hollywood. Glad you enjoy Sherlock Bingo!

  3. Pingback: Schedule: DYNAMIC DUOS in Classic Film blogathon | Once upon a screen...

  4. I enjoyed your write-up, although I have never seen a Sherlock Holmes movie!

  5. Judy says:

    It’s a pity that Nigel Bruce had to turn Watson into a buffoon, but he and Rathbone definitely make a fine combination! The Sherlock Bingo is great, really enjoyed this.

  6. Le says:

    This is relevant to me since I’m reading A stufy in scarlett. Too bad to know that Watson became comic relief, since he is such a prepared doctor in the book. Maybe Jude Law is te one that made the most accurate Watson?
    Anyway, these Rathbone-Bruce movies sound like a must-see!
    Don’t forget to read my contribution to the blogathon! 🙂

    • Anne Marie says:

      Hi! I hope you enjoy Study in Scarlett. It’s one of my favorites.

      I’m not a big fan if Jude Law. I think he is as far from an accurate representation of Watson as Nigel Bruce. Law just skews way, way to the opposite end of the spectrum to become Action Movie Watson. The most true-to-the-books Watson is Edward Hardwicke from the fantastic 1980s series with Jeremy Brett.

  7. Pingback: Schedule: DYNAMIC DUOS in Classic Film blogathon | Classic Movie Hub Blog

  8. Hi there! Thanks for the great post. I think I may have to play some Sherlock bingo! 😉

  9. NeveR says:

    Thank you for celebrating Basil. He needs more love 🙂

  10. Pingback: Sexy Sherlock and a Modern Moriarty | We Recycle Movies

  11. Antonetta says:

    Very informative article, i am regular reader of your website.
    I noticed that your website is outranked by many other
    blogs in google’s search results. You deserve to be in top ten. I
    know what can help you, search in google for:
    Omond’s tips outsource the work

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s