5 Movie Musicals So Nice They Made Them Twice

As last week’s post on Show Boat showed, Hollywood has a history of repeating itself. (This is fortunate for me; otherwise this blog wouldn’t exist!) Here are 5 less complicated musicals that have been given the Hollywood treatment over and over.

5. Sparkle (1976
& 2012) Sparkle was a proto-Dreamgirls, an early Motown musical based not-so-subtly on the Supremes and other girl groups of the ’70s. It boasted music by Curtis Mayfield (of “Superfly” fame). The remake was supposed to be a launch for an American Idol starlette. However, it’s best known for being Whitney Houston’s last film. Houston’s music packs a punch even though she’s only given one song. The rest of music is mostly forgettable in both films

4. Babes In Toyland (1961 &
– This is rather a tangle because there are 4 movies listed under this title and none of them have the same plot. First came an Abbot & Costello film. Next was a 1961 Disney movie with music by Victor Herbert. Then came a 1986 TV movie with Drew Barrymore (but no music). Finally, in 1997 there was a cartoon version that also had music by Victor Herbert but a different lyricist. Did that make sense to you? Yes? Then explain it to me. I’m still confused.

the-jazz-singer-movie-poster-1980-1020193094 250px-JazzsingerPP
3. The Jazz Singer
(1980 & 1927) – If you were going to remake the groundbreaking film that introduced sound to cinema, you’d have to be gutsy. Looking closer at the film, it’s really a so-so story about a Jewish cantor’s son breaking into showbiz. The big moment is a very uncomfortable (and unfortunately iconic) blackface number. You know the one: “Mammy! Mammy!” If you wanted to make this film successful, you’d probably cast Neil Diamond. But why would you want to make this film at all?

4da167b47b42cedc21eda925acac1c94_XL 600full-cinderella-(1957-television-production)-cover 1003780r
2. Cinderella (1957 & 1965 &
The Rogers & Hammerstein musical so nice they made it 3 times! The first was for a young starlette named Julie Andrews. It was in the days of live TV, so the entire thing was a well-orchestrated television event. By the second go around (starring Leslie Ann Warren), pre-recording had come about. The third was just a wild and wonderful musical starring Brandi for some reason, with a few Rogers & Hart songs thrown in. The cast for all three was spectacular: the first included comedienne Kay Ballard. The second starred Celeste Holm, Ginger Rogers, and Pat Carroll (Ursula). The third featured Whoopi Goldberg, Bernadette Peters, Jason Alexander, and of course Whitney Houston as the fairy godmother. I really love these musicals.

1. Oklahoma (1955 & 1955)
– Yes, this is one movie. It was shot two times. In the 1950s, 20th Century Fox was exploring new widescreen technologies. They’d already had success in 1953 with The Robe in CinemaScope. But Mike Todd (best known for marrying Elizabeth Taylor) was marketing a new 70mm widescreen format called Todd-AO. Todd-AO was flashy but complicated, so it was primarily used for big road shows. For wide release, 35mm CinemaScope was necessary. This meant that Oklahoma! had to be shot twice. The video below shows an example (skip to 3 minutes):

Of course, I haven’t covered all of the twice-made movie musicals here. What are your favorites?

About Anne Marie Kelly

Classic Film history & restoration nerd. Writer of A Year With Kate and Women's Pictures for The Film Experience. Follow me on Twitter @WeRecycleMovies.
This entry was posted in Film, Musicals and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to 5 Movie Musicals So Nice They Made Them Twice

  1. Mrs says:

    I am torn on which version of Annie I like best, though Carol Burnett as Miss Hannigan is a top favorite. The later made for TV version has Alan Cumming and Kristin Chenoweth to compare with Tim Curryand Bernadette Peters. We can all judge again when a 3rd version comes out next year.
    And then there is State Fair, made in an non-musical version with Will Rogers in the 30’s and adapted to a musical in 1945. It is the only movie R & H wrote first for the screen and then produced on Broadway. Dana Andrews is wonderful in this pre- The Best Years of our Lives appearance. This was an early film for Vivian Blaine; she and Dick Haymes sing their own songs. The 1962 version was merely a Pat Boone vehicle with Ann-Margret thrown in for sex appeal (she was better in Bye Bye Birdie). The “bad girl” against “good boy” device ruins the charm of the original plot and has more treacle (if possible) than either prior version .

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s